What Remedy is doing here
Alan Wake 2 is a survival horror game in structure, but it's also a meta-fictional game about storytelling, a musical, a procedural detective drama, and a Remedy greatest-hits reel. The fact that it holds together at all is impressive. The fact that it sometimes doesn't is forgivable given how much it's attempting.
You play as two characters: Alan Wake, the writer trapped in the Dark Place, and Saga Anderson, an FBI agent investigating murders connected to Wake's fiction. The two halves play differently — Wake's sections are more linear and atmospheric, Saga's have an investigation mechanic and a wider open structure. Both are interesting.
The second half
There's a point roughly in the middle where both storylines converge and the game becomes something stranger and more confident. The final few hours are as inventive as anything in the survival horror genre, including the musical sequence that you'll have heard about. It earns it.
The first half takes longer to get going. Saga's investigation mechanics are underexplained. Some of the early environments are repeated more than they should be. But if you push through to where the game finds its rhythm, it pays off significantly.
What works
- Second half is genuinely inventive and memorable
- Two protagonists with meaningfully different playstyles
- The musical sequence is unlike anything else
- Visually excellent on Xbox Series X
What doesn't
- Slow start — takes a few hours to get going
- Investigation mechanics are underexplained
- Some early environments are reused too much
Verdict
Alan Wake 2 is the most ambitious thing Remedy has made. It doesn't all work, but what does work is genuinely memorable. Is it worth buying? If you have patience for a slow start and an appetite for strange storytelling, yes. Don't expect a straightforward horror game.
See our editorial policy and disclosure.