Skip to main content
Alphaconsolefeed

Console Buying Guide — PS5 vs Xbox Series X vs Nintendo Switch

Which console should you buy? The honest answer depends on a few things, and the marketing won't tell you what they are. We will.

By Sanne Boer1 August 2024Playtime: Guide — all three consoles owned and used
Gaming controller macro close-up

The real question

Most console comparison articles spend a lot of time on specs. The processor speed, the frame rate ceiling, the teraflops. That information exists and can be looked up. What's harder to find is an honest answer to the actual question: which of these consoles has the games you want to play?

That's what this guide is about.

PlayStation 5 — for whom

The PS5 has the strongest lineup of single-player narrative exclusives right now. Astro Bot, Spider-Man 2, God of War, Horizon, The Last of Us — these are games that are not available anywhere else and that represent some of the best production values in console gaming. The DualSense controller is genuinely innovative, not just marketed as such. If you want story-driven games and don't have a gaming PC, the PS5 is the strongest argument.

Xbox Series X — for whom

Game Pass is the Xbox's differentiator. If the idea of paying a monthly fee to access a large rotating library of games appeals to you — and it does for a certain kind of gamer who likes variety and doesn't always finish every game they start — this is a compelling ecosystem. If you also game on PC, the Microsoft ecosystem means your Xbox purchases carry over. The Bethesda acquisition means ongoing large open-world releases. The hardware is as powerful as the PS5.

Nintendo Switch — for whom

The Switch is its own category. It's the only console that's also a handheld, and that portability is genuinely useful if your gaming time is fragmented. The game library is built around Nintendo franchises that don't exist anywhere else — Zelda, Mario, Pokémon, Animal Crossing, Splatoon. If you want those games, there's no substitute. The hardware is old and shows it in performance, but the software routinely compensates.

What works

  • Honest about the trade-offs of each platform
  • Based on direct experience with all three consoles
  • Focused on game libraries rather than spec sheets

What doesn't

  • Best pick changes over time as libraries evolve — check publication date
  • Personal taste is the most important variable we cannot account for

Verdict

There is no universally correct answer. The PS5 wins on exclusive single-player games. Xbox wins on value through Game Pass and PC integration. Switch wins on portability and Nintendo exclusives. Figure out which of those things matters most to you. If you're still not sure, try our five-question comparison guide.